New research from Alchemy, a global circular technology company, reveals a significant gap between consumer interest in trade-in programs and their availability at the point of purchase. While 78% of U.S. shoppers consider trading in products, only 50% were offered a trade-in option during their most recent purchase. The findings highlight an opportunity for retailers to better meet consumer demand, expand trade-in programs, and support the circular economy.
The study was conducted for Alchemy by FDM CCS Insight across 11,217 consumers in the US, UK, Germany and Poland. It shows that merely having a trade-in program is not enough – it needs to be accessible and worthwhile.
A clear commercial opportunity for brands
Trade-in encourages consumers to trade up: 74% say a competitive trade-in value would make them more likely to choose a higher-end product than they had planned, and three quarters (76%) say they would upgrade sooner if their preferred brand offered good trade-in value. 68% would also be more likely to add accessories, warranties or other items to their basket.
The benefits also extend to how consumers see the brand itself. Seven in ten (71%) say offering trade-in improves their perception of a brand, with affordability the leading reason: 44% of them say it makes upgrading feel more affordable.
Trade-in is the lever that makes a premium upgrade easier. Seven in ten US consumers (72%) agree that trading in is a smart way to get value back from old products, and upgrading to a better model is the single most common reason people trade in (29%).
When asked what would make it easier to buy or upgrade to a more premium product, a trade-in discount comes out on top (37%), ahead of paying monthly (29%) or subscription options (21%).
Value is the biggest driver. 27% of US consumers say the value offered is the main factor shaping whether they trade in, 22% want values to be presented more clearly, and 21% say they would benefit from greater awareness that older products still hold value. As the report puts it, well-designed trade-in makes upgrading feel less like spending and more like getting value back.
Additionally, certainty and transparency in trade-in programs build confidence.
67% say a guaranteed price lock after an online quote would increase their trust, and 64% want the ability to return a product if the final valuation differs from the estimate.
Stephen Wise, Director Global Marketing at Alchemy, said:
“Trade-in has moved well beyond a sustainability initiative or a way to reduce the cost of a new device. It is now one of the clearest signals of how competitive a brand’s overall proposition is – and consumers are telling us they are prepared to choose, and stay with, the brands that get it right.”
“The research is a strong vote of confidence in trade-in. The brands that pair competitive value with certainty, transparency and choice will be the ones that win new customers, deepen loyalty, bring upgrades forward and recover more devices for a second life.”
The full research report is published on Alchemy’s website in two free playbooks. The first is designed to help brands already active in trade-in optimize their programs, while the second is tailored to provide insights for those new to the space to help them grow nascent programs.
Visit Optimizing established trade-in programs: https://www.wearealchemy.com/research-and-insights/optimizing-established-trade-in-programs
Building participation in emerging trade-in programs: https://www.wearealchemy.com/research-and-insights/building-participation-in-emerging-trade-in-programs
Visit Alchemy to learn more: wearealchemy.com
The Refurbished Market Isn’t Struggling To Be Seen; It’s Struggling To Be Chosen